we have been doing much thinking since we wrote last. we have been on our period, and whenever we are menstruating we need alone time. that time seems to always lead us to think and feel and process.
these last many days we have been thinking a lot about culpability…we did horrible things during those dark 21 years. some in us justify it by saying we had no choice…but others quickly jump in and say that we did have a choice–we could have chosen to be the one tortured and killed.
we have always felt a deep connection with the Holocaust and survivors of it. During that time people did what they had to in order to survive in the most depraved situations. still arguments rage inside us…even in those dark times there were heroes who refused to give in…refused to sacrifice their values and morals.
what was the difference between those of us who did whatever we needed to in order to survive and those who died heroes? i want to think of myself as a good person…but in my black and white thinking, the good ones were the heroes. we see ourselves as bad for being like the perps. i know, intellectually, that things aren’t black and white. we still struggle with that. it is so much easier to see the perps as all bad…but where does that leave us?
we’ve been watching movies about the Holocaust and other tragedies, such as the Rowandan genocide. In one of these films, titled “The Cross and the Star” several statements stood out to us. I am going to quote them here.
“In the barbaric conditions of the camps, there was hardly room for ethical discussion. Moral conduct was a luxury in a situation that defied categories of human comportment. Wherein victims were driven by fear, despair and death at every moment.” (narrator)
“Values are a privilege, and even a luxury, for those of us who are free to adopt them, appreciate them, form them and use them. They’re not something we can use or cling to under the stringent situation of atrocity in the camps.” (Prof. Lawrence Langer)
“…just tried to survive the next hour. And let me say, this was the driving motivation. There was no strength or time for philosophizing.” (Samuel Natansohn, Polish Holocaust survivor)
all of these quotes, and the movies/books and our own history, make me think that maybe the morals we can have in a sane situation are completely different from how we survive in an unsane one. this society teaches us that values and morals are immovable, that they must remain the same no matter what. but are they? the human instinct is the survive.
and then their is the voice of the wise one…who is whispering that some peoples job/purpose is to be a hero…and other peoples purpose is the live at whatever cost…to live and tell the tale. to not let the story be forgotten. i suppose that means we are one of these storytellers.